中国组织工程研究 ›› 2024, Vol. 28 ›› Issue (12): 1810-1814.doi: 10.12307/2024.045

• 骨与关节生物力学 bone and joint biomechanics • 上一篇    下一篇

不同复位条件下股骨颈骨折最优固定方式的有限元分析

韩  彪,李  冀,李  彬,孙  博,宗双乐,王宏润,李冬梅,李力更,王  斌   

  1. 唐山市第二医院,河北省唐山市   063000
  • 收稿日期:2023-03-14 接受日期:2023-04-20 出版日期:2024-04-28 发布日期:2023-08-22
  • 通讯作者: 李冀,博士,主任医师,唐山市第二医院,河北省唐山市 063000
  • 作者简介:韩彪,男,1989年生,河北省迁安市人,汉族,2018年天津医科大学毕业,硕士,主治医师,主要从事骨外科学常见疾病诊治研究。
  • 基金资助:
    2020年度唐山市人才项目 (A202003026),项目负责人:李冀

Finite element analysis of optimal fixation method for femoral neck fracture with different reduction conditions

Han Biao, Li Ji, Li Bin, Sun Bo, Zong Shuangle, Wang Hongrun, Li Dongmei, Li Ligeng, Wang Bin   

  1. The Second Hospital of Tangshan, Tangshan 063000, Hebei Province, China
  • Received:2023-03-14 Accepted:2023-04-20 Online:2024-04-28 Published:2023-08-22
  • Contact: Li Ji, MD, Chief physician, The Second Hospital of Tangshan, Tangshan 063000, Hebei Province, China
  • About author:Han Biao, Master, Attending physician, The Second Hospital of Tangshan, Tangshan 063000, Hebei Province, China
  • Supported by:
    2020 Tangshan Talent Project, No. A202003026 (to LJ)

摘要:


文题释义:

股骨颈骨折按骨折部位分型:股骨颈骨折按解剖部位可分为头下型骨折、经颈型骨折、基底型骨折,头下型骨折为骨折线位于头下,股骨头坏死风险最大;经颈型骨折为骨折线斜行经过股骨颈处,股骨头坏死率次于头下型骨折;基底型骨折为骨折线处于股骨颈基底部,该型骨折是股骨颈骨折中股骨头坏死率最低的,因而此次研究的骨折模型选用的是头下型骨折。
按骨折复位条件选用固定方式的策略:目前临床应用最为广泛的股骨颈骨折的固定方式为3枚空心螺钉倒三角固定,该传统固定方式需考虑骨折复位条件,如骨折复位未达到解剖复位,其是否仍为最佳固定方式目前尚无定论,因而此次研究从生物力线的角度出发,应用有限元分析的方法,探究股骨颈骨折的个性化固定方案,结果显示根据不同复位条件,适当调整螺钉角度,具备生物力学方面的优越性。


背景:股骨颈骨折的传统固定方式为3枚空心螺钉倒三角固定,对于未达到解剖复位的股骨颈骨折的最优固定方式尚无定论。

目的:基于有限元分析法比较空心钉固定不同复位条件下头下型股骨颈骨折的生物力学性能。
方法:选取一名健康成年男性股骨近端CT数据重建三维模型,进行头下型骨折造模,将骨折模型分为解剖复位组、髋内翻组、髋外翻组,各骨折模型组均分出3个亚组,用标准组、螺钉压低组、螺钉抬高组进行转配,于髋臼顶向股骨头施加垂直向下1 400 N的应力,观察不同固定方式下股骨及内固定物的位移和应力分布,对比股骨和固定物的应力和位移最大值。

结果与结论:①解剖复位时,标准组、螺钉压低组、螺钉抬高组固定物应力峰值分别为41.35,31.27,43.32 MPa,螺钉抬高组的股骨应力峰值最大(28.58 MPa),股骨的位移峰值标准组最大;②髋内翻时,3个亚组的应力均相对分散且均匀;标准组的股骨应力峰值最小,但位移峰值最大,固定的稳定性可能不佳;螺钉压低组股骨的位移峰值最小;③在髋外翻时,螺钉压低组出现明显的螺钉应力集中,且位移峰值为3个亚组中最大,出现in-out-in现象;螺钉抬高组螺钉的应力峰值为3个亚组中最大,但位移峰值最小;④提示在头下型股骨颈骨折中,当完全解剖复位时,推荐采用标准的倒三角置钉方式固定;当出现复位标准允许范围内的髋内翻及髋外翻,置入螺钉时,推荐采用随髋内或外翻同方向转动相应的角度置入倒三角螺钉固定。

https://orcid.org/0009-0005-0680-8531 (韩彪) 

中国组织工程研究杂志出版内容重点:人工关节;骨植入物;脊柱;骨折;内固定;数字化骨科;组织工程

关键词: 股骨颈骨折, 内固定, 有限元分析, 复位质量, 生物力学

Abstract: BACKGROUND: The traditional fixation method for femoral neck fractures is three hollow screws inverted triangle fixation, and the optimal fixation method for femoral neck fractures that have not achieved anatomical reduction is inconclusive.
OBJECTIVE: To compare the biomechanical properties of cannulated screws internal fixation for sub-capitated femoral neck fracture with different reduction qualities based on finite element analysis. 
METHODS: The three-dimensional digital model was reconstructed using CT data of the proximal femur from a healthy male volunteer. The femur was modeled to sub-capitated femoral neck fractures. Fracture models were divided into anatomical reduction group, coxa vara group, and coxa valgus group. All fracture model groups were transferred using the standard group, screw depression group, and screw elevation group. A vertical downward stress of 1 400 N was applied to the femoral head at the top of the acetabulum. The displacement and stress distribution of the femur and internal fixator under different fixation methods were observed, and the maximum stress and displacement of the femur and fixator were compared. 
RESULTS AND CONCLUSION: (1) For anatomical reduction femoral neck fracture, the peak stress of fixation in the standard group, screw depression group and screw elevation group was 41.35, 31.27 and 43.32 MPa, respectively. The maximum peak stress of the femur was found on the screw elevation group (28.58 MPa), and the standard group had the maximum peak displacement. (2) During hip varus, the stresses in the three subgroups were relatively dispersed and even. The peak stress of the femur in the standard group was the smallest, but the peak displacement was the largest. The stability of fixation might be poor. The peak displacement of the femur in the screw depression group was the smallest. (3) In the hip valgus, obvious screw stress concentration appeared in the screw depression group, and the peak displacement was the largest among the three subgroups, and an in-out-in phenomenon appeared. The peak stress of the screws in the screw elevation group was the largest among the three subgroups, but the peak displacement was the smallest. (4) It is concluded that for sub-capitated femoral neck fractures that are completely anatomically reduced, it is recommended to use standard inverted triangular nails for fixation. When the hip varus and hip valgus occur within the allowable range of the reduction standard, it is recommended to use the inverted triangle screw to fix it by rotating the corresponding angle in the same direction as the hip varus or valgus.

Key words: femoral neck fracture, internal fixation, finite element analysis, reduction quality, biomechanics 

中图分类号: