中国组织工程研究 ›› 2024, Vol. 28 ›› Issue (16): 2579-2586.doi: 10.12307/2024.299

• 口腔组织构建 oral tissue construction • 上一篇    下一篇

骨质对右上第一磨牙种植修复体咬合调整影响的有限元分析

陈佳文1,罗思阳2,刘  印2,陈光能1,左瑀雯1,贺酰钰2,马敏先2   

  1. 1贵州医科大学附属口腔医院,贵州省贵阳市  550000;2贵阳市口腔医院,贵州省贵阳市  550000
  • 收稿日期:2023-03-30 接受日期:2023-05-10 出版日期:2024-06-08 发布日期:2023-07-31
  • 通讯作者: 马敏先,博士,主任医师,贵阳市口腔医院,贵州省贵阳市 550000
  • 作者简介:陈佳文,男,1995年生,贵州省黔南州人,苗族,贵州医科大学在读硕士,主要从事口腔种植临床技能训练及研究。
  • 基金资助:
    贵州省卫生计生委科学技术基金项目(gzwjkj2018-1-052),项目负责人:罗思阳

Finite element analysis of the effect of bone on occlusal adjustment of right upper first molar implants

Chen Jiawen1, Luo Siyang2, Liu Yin2, Chen Guangneng1, Zuo Yuwen1, He Xianyu2, Ma Minxian2   

  1. 1Affiliated Stomatological Hospital of Guizhou Medical University, Guiyang 550000, Guizhou Province, China; 2Guiyang Hospital of Stomatology, Guiyang 550000, Guizhou Province, China
  • Received:2023-03-30 Accepted:2023-05-10 Online:2024-06-08 Published:2023-07-31
  • Contact: Ma Minxian, MD, Chief physician, Guiyang Hospital of Stomatology, Guiyang 550000, Guizhou Province, China
  • About author:Chen Jiawen, Master candidate, Affiliated Stomatological Hospital of Guizhou Medical University, Guiyang 550000, Guizhou Province, China
  • Supported by:
    Science and Technology Project of Guizhou Provincial Health and Family Planning Commission, No. gzwjkj2018-1-052 (to LSY)

摘要:


文题释义:

种植修复体咬合间隙:由于种植体与天然牙生理动度存在的明显差异,种植体可能会承担所有咬合力,因此临床操作时,可通过在修复体和对颌牙齿之间预留一定的空间来消除种植体和牙齿之间的动度差异。
有限元分析法:是一种实用有效的理论应力分析方法,它通过将整体结构看作互相连接而成的有限个单元,对每个单元的性质进行依次研究,每个单元力学特征的总体组合效果可以反映构件的整体力学特性。


背景:骨组织改建与应力加载密切相关,目前就骨质与种植修复体咬合调整关系的研究或指南较少,并且缺乏科学的证据。

目的:通过有限元方法探究不同种植修复体咬合间隙在Ⅰ-Ⅳ类骨质条件下时对种植体-骨界面应力分布、应力峰值、位移的影响。
方法:通过光学扫描仪扫描等比例牙齿模型后,使用Solidworks 2022构建等比例右上第一磨牙Straumann 4.8×8 mm BL RC种植体及其相关部件模型,再利用Mimics、Geomagic、Solidworks软件,依据文献ZARB和LEKHOLM提出的骨质分类、NORTON和TRISI骨质密度分类,建立Ⅰ-Ⅳ类骨质的上下颌骨模型。以0,20,40,60,80,100 μm为修复体咬合间隙完成模型的装配,并且额外构建一组未进行密度比设置的均质模型作为对比。将上述模型导入Hypermesh进行网格划分后,进行有限元分析的材料赋值、边界约束以及参数设定,最后以250 N为加载力模拟上下颌受力情况,分析比较各组模型中种植体-骨界面的应力分布、应力峰值和位移情况。

结果与结论:①相同荷载条件下,种植修复体应力随咬合接触点均匀分布,当咬合间隙达80 μm和100 μm时,Ⅰ类骨质和Ⅱ、Ⅲ、Ⅳ类骨质下的种植牙冠分别出现应力中断现象。②种植体-骨界面的位移主要集中在种植体周围的皮质骨区并沿种植体长轴向下传导至底部的松质骨区域。随着Ⅰ-Ⅳ类颌骨骨质的减弱,各组模型皮质骨区产生的位移、Von Mises应力均呈现增加趋势,且均较松质骨区大。而松质骨区Von Mises应力除自Ⅱ类骨起则呈下降趋势外,其余均与皮质骨区相类似,但当咬合间隙增大时,皮质骨及松质骨区产生的应力及位移峰值则呈现逐渐减小趋势。③在咬合间隙为0-40 μm的Ⅱ-Ⅳ类骨质条件下以及60 μm的Ⅳ类骨质条件时,种植体-骨组织界面应力均介于20-60 MPa之间,其余各组应力均< 20 MPa。④种植体Von Mises应力主要集中于种植体颈部,在咬合间隙为20 μm的Ⅱ-Ⅳ类骨质条件下,种植体应力峰值均大于咬合间隙为0 μm、Ⅰ类骨质条件下的144.10 MPa。⑤在不同弹性模量的均质模型中,其应力及位移分布较非均质模型更加均匀。⑥结论:实验结果从生物力学的角度证明种植义齿修复的咬合调整应该将牙槽骨骨质纳入考虑因素,临床工作中咬合间隙应随着颌骨密度的下降而增加,单颗种植牙与对颌天然牙的咬合间隙在20-40 μm是一个相对合适的咬合调整方案。但由于有限元分析法的特殊性,还有待结合临床进行进一步的深入研究。 

https://orcid.org/0009-0000-6215-0299(陈佳文)

中国组织工程研究杂志出版内容重点:组织构建;骨细胞;软骨细胞;细胞培养;成纤维细胞;血管内皮细胞;骨质疏松;组织工程

关键词: 种植体, 骨质, 应力, 咬合空间, 咬合接触, 三维有限元

Abstract: BACKGROUND: Bone tissue remodeling is closely related to stress loading. Currently, there are few studies or guidelines on the relationship between bone and occlusal adjustment of implant prostheses and there is also a lack of scientific evidence.
OBJECTIVE: To investigate the effects of different implant occlusal gaps on stress distribution, stress peak and displacement at the implant-bone interface under I-IV bone conditions by a finite element method.
METHODS: After scanning the equal-scale tooth model with an optical scanner, equal-scale models of the upper right first molar Straumann 4.8×8 mm BL RC implant and its related components was constructed using Solidworks 2022. Then, using Mimics, Geomagic, and Solidworks software, the maxillary and mandibular bone models of class I-IV bones were established based on the bone classification proposed by ZARB and LEKHOLM in the literature, and the NORTON and TRISI bone density classification method. The models were assembled with the occlusal gaps of 0, 20, 40, 60, 80, and 100 μm for the restorations, and an additional set of homogeneous models without density ratio settings was constructed for comparison. After the above models were imported into Hypermesh for meshing, the material assignment, boundary constraints and parameter setting were performed for the finite element analysis. Finally, 250 N was used as the loading force to simulate the maxillary and mandibular stress conditions. Stress distribution, peak stress and displacement of the implant-bone interface in each group of models were analyzed and compared.
RESULTS AND CONCLUSION: Under the same loading conditions, the stresses in the implant restorations were evenly distributed with the occlusal contact points. When the occlusal gap reached 80 and 100 μm, stress interruptions occurred in the implant crowns under class I bone and class II, III and IV bones, respectively. The displacement of the implant-bone interface was mainly concentrated in the cortical bone region around the implant and transmitted down the long axis of the implant to the cancellous bone region at the bottom. With the changes of class I-IV jaw bones, the displacement and Von Mises stress in the cortical bone region increased in all groups, and were greater than those in the cancellous bone region. The Von Mises stress in the cancellous bone region was similar to that in the cortical bone region except that it showed a downward trend from class II bone. However, when the occlusal gap increased, the stress and displacement peak values in the cortical bone and the cancellous bone showed a decreasing trend. The stress of the implant-bone interface was between 20 MPa and 60 MPa when the occlusal gap was 0-40 μm for class II-IV bones and 60 μm for class IV bone, and the stress of the other groups was less than     20 MPa. The Von Mises stress was mainly concentrated in the neck of the implant, and the peak value of von Mises stress in class II-IV bones with the occlusal gap of 20 μm was higher than that (144.10 MPa) in class I bone with the occlusal gap of 0 μm. In the homogeneous model with different elastic moduli, the distribution of stress and displacement was more uniform than that in the heterogeneous model and the occlusal space should increase with the decrease of jaw bone density in clinical practice. To conclude, from the perspective of biomechanics, the alveolar bone should be taken into account in the occlusal adjustment of implant denture. An occlusal gap of 20-40 μm between a single dental implant and a natural tooth in the opposite jaw is a relatively suitable solution for occlusal adjustment under different bone conditions. However, due to the particularity of finite element analysis method, it needs to be further studied in combination with clinical practice. 

Key words: implant, bone, stress, occlusal gap, occlusal contact, three-dimensional finite element

中图分类号: