BACKGROUND: During the orthodontic treatment, the results of related reports on
potential risk factors affecting the clinical success rate of miniscrew
implants are inconsistent. The influential factors that clinicians concern are
not all included in this study, and the conclusions from animal experiments are
difficult to apply to clinical practice directly. Therefore, what factors
affect the clinical success rate of miniscrew implants need further thorough
and systematic research.
OBJECTIVE: To investigate the factors that influence the clinical success rate of
miniscrew implants used as orthodontic anchorage.
METHODS: A total of 114 patients with oral implants, including 42 males and 72
females, aged (19.26±9.19) years were included in this study. A total of 253
miniscrew implants were implanted as orthodontic anchorage. The following
influential factors were included: gender, age, vertical skeletal facial
pattern, implant site, implant arch, soft tissue type at the implant site, oral
hygiene status, diameter and length of the miniscrew implants, implantation
method, implantation angle, stress loading timing and intensity, and clinical
use. Logistic regression analysis was used to study the correlation between
success rate and all variables. Analysis of variance was used to test the
effect of each variable on clinical success rate. This trial protocol was
approved by the Medical Ethics Committee of Sichuan University.
RESULTS AND CONCLUSION: Among 253 successful miniscrew implants, the overall success rate was 88.54% with an average loading period of 9.5 months. The average loading period of the 29 failed miniscrew implants was 2.3 months. The chi-square test, Fisher exact test and Logistic regression revealed that age, oral hygiene, vertical skeletal facial pattern, and implant site were significantly correlated with clinical success rate (P < 0.05). However, gender, sagittal bone facial patter, implant arch, soft tissue type at implant site, diameter and length of miniscrew implant, implantation method, implantation angle, stress loading timing and strength, and clinical use were not significantly correlated to clinical use (P > 0.05). These results suggest that to minimize the failure of miniscrew implants, proper oral hygiene instruction and effective supervision should be given to patients, in particular to those young (< 12 years) high mandibular plane patients.