Clinical comparison of two kinds of orthodontic adhesives bonding buccal tubes of posterior teeth

doi:10.3969/j.issn.2095-4344.2014.16.013

Abstract

Abstract:

BACKGROUND: Currently, buccal tubes are mostly preferred rather than molar bands to control posterior tooth movement. However, the buccal tube is difficult to bind the molar because of its position. Meanwhile, due to the relatively large masticatory forces on the posterior tooth, the buccal tube is easier to drop off.

OBJECTIVE: To investigate the clinical effects of two kinds of adhesives bonding the buccal tube.

METHODS: Sixty orthodontic patients were selected randomly. The right side of the upper and lower first molars of each patient was bonded by 3M Transbond^TM light-cured resin binder, and the left side of the upper and lower first molar of each patient was bonded by 3M chemical curing adhesive. Cases of buccal tube shedding were recorded within 4 months. Meanwhile, 3M Transbond^TM light-cured resin binder and 3M chemical curing adhesive were used to bond the isolated human first molar, respectively. The normal oral environment and temperature were stimulated, and the shear bonding strength was measured after measured after 10 000 thermal cycles.

RESULTS AND CONCLUSION: The dropout rate of 3M Transbond^TM light-cured resin binder and 3M chemical curing adhesive groups was 10.80% and 24.10% respectively, and there was a significant difference (P < 0.05). In vitro experiments confirmed that two kinds of adhesives could meet the clinical requirements, but 3M Transbond^TM light-cured resin binder was better than 3M chemical curing adhesive. These findings indicate that compared with 3M chemical curing adhesive, 3M Transbond^TM light-cured resin binder is more suitable for the binding between the molar and buccal tubes.

中国组织工程研究杂志出版内容重点：生物材料；骨生物材料; 口腔生物材料; 纳米材料; 缓释材料; 材料相容性；组织工程

全文链接：

Key words: biocompatible materials, resin cements, dental cements, orthodontics, corrective

CLC Number:

R318

Wang Fa-sheng, Li Dong. Clinical comparison of two kinds of orthodontic adhesives bonding buccal tubes of posterior teeth[J]. Chinese Journal of Tissue Engineering Research, 2014, 18(16): 2538-2543.

Figures/Tables 1

References

[1] 杜晓岩,尹艳春.3M自酸蚀黏结剂与GC光固化正畸黏结剂黏结颊面管性能比较研究[J].中国实用口腔科杂志,2010,3(3): 155-157．
[2] 蒋丽,王海雪,王鑫.两种正畸粘结剂粘结颊面管临床效果评价及护理配合[J].西南国防医药,2012,22(12):1339-1341．
[3] Gorelick L,Geiger AM,Gwinnetth AJ.Incidence of white spotformation after bonding and banding.Am J Orthod. 1982; 81(2):93-98.
[4] Thurmond JW, Barkmeier WW, Wilwerding TM.Effect of porcelain surface treatments on bond strengths of composite resin bonded to porcelain.J Prosthet Dent.1994;72 (4): 355-359.
[5] Nebbe B,Stein E. Orthodontic brackets bonded to glazed and deglazed porcelain surfaces.Am J Orthod. 1996;109(4): 431-436.
[6] Chunhacheevachaloke E,Tyas MJ.Shear bond strength of ceramic brackets to resin-composite surfaces.Aust Orthod J. 1997;15(1):10-15.
[7] Buonocore MG.A simple method of increasing the adhesion of acrylic filling materials to enamel surface.J Dent Res. 1995;34:849.
[8] Cook PA,Ymmgon C.An in vitro study of the bond strength of aglass iononler cement in the direct bonding of orthodontic brackets.Br J Orthod.1988;15:247-253．
[9] 段娇红,宋九余.三种正畸粘结剂的粘结强度及残留指数比较[J].中国组织工程研究与临床康复,2008,12(19):3671-3673．
[10] 陈治清,管利民.口腔粘接学[M].北京:北京医科大学中国协和医科大学联合出版社,1993:90.
[11] Graber TM.口腔正畸学现代原理与技术[M].徐芸译.天津:天津科技翻译出版公司,1996:562.
[12] 历松.不同拖槽与弓丝之间动态摩擦力的研究[D].成都:华西医科大学,2001.
[13] Newman GV.Epoxy adhesives for orthodontic attachments progress report.Am J Orthod.1965;51(12):901-912.
[14] 徐宝华.现代临床口腔正畸学[M].北京:人民卫生出版社, 1996:272.
[15] Liobell A,Nichols JI,Kois JC,et al.Fatigue life of porcelain repair systems. Int J Prosthod.1992;5(2):205-213.
[16] Reynolds IR,Fraunhofer JA.Direct bonding in orthodontic attachments to teeth:the relation of adhesive bond strength to gauze mesh size.Br J Orthod.1975;3(1):91-95.
[17] 高晓辉,吴晶,杨圣辉,等.不同材质拖槽对菌斑附着的实验研究[J].首都医科大学学报,2002,23(9):3.
[18] Roulet JF,Soderholm KJM,Longmate J. Effects of treatment and storage conditions on ceramic/composite bond strength.J Dent Res.1995;74(1):381-387.
[19] Ozden AN,Akaltan F,Can G.Effect of surface treatments of porcelain on the shear bond strength of applied dual-cured cement.J Prosthet Dent.1994;72(1):85-88.
[20] Cochran D,Okeefe KL,Turner DT,et al.Bond strength of orthodontic composite cement to treated porcelain.Am J Orthod Dentofac Orthop.1997;111(3):297-300.
[21] Thurmond JW,Barkmeier WW,Wilwerding TM. Effect of porcelain surface treatments on bond strengths of composite resin bonded to porcelain.J Prosthet Dent.1994;72 (4):355-359.
[22] Plueddemann EP.Shane coupling agents. New York:Plenum Press,1982.
[23] 纪昌蓉,王邦康,张晋宏,等.京津釉质粘合剂在口腔正畸临床应用的评价[J].中华口腔医学杂志,1990,25(2):76-78.
[24] Barbosa VL,Almeida MA,Chevitarese O,et al.Direct bonding to porcelain.Am J Orthod Dentofac Orthop.1995;107(2): 159-164.
[25] Zachrisson VO,Zachrisson BU,Buyukyilmaz T.Surface preparation for Orthodontic bonding to porcelain.Am J Orthod Dentofac Orthop.1996;109(4):420-430.
[26] Ozcan M,Niedermeier W.Clinical study on the reasons for and location of failures of metal-ceramic restorations and survival of repairs.Int J Prosthodont.2002;15(3):299-302.
[27] Sant'Anna EF,Monnerat ME,Chevitarese O,et al.Bonding brackets to porcelain--in vitro study. Braz Dent J.2002;13(3): 191-196.
[28] Kato H,Matsumura H,Tanaka T,et al.Bond strength and durability of porcelain bonding systems.J Prosthet Dent.1996; 75(2):163-168.
[29] Ozcan M,Vallittu PK,Peltomaki T,et al.Bonding polycarbonate brackets to ceramic: effects of substrate treatment on bond strength.Am J Orthod Dentofacorthop. 2004;126(2):220-227.
[30] Brantley WA,Eliades T.Orthodontics Materials. New York: Thieme,2011:256-258.
[31] Hegarty DJ,Macfarlane TV.In vivo bracket retention comparison of a resin-modified glass ionomer cement and a resin-based bracket adhesive systerm after a year. Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop.2002;121(5):496-501.
[32] Dominey JC,Dunn W J,Taloum is LJ.Shear bond strength of orthodontic brackets bonded with a modified 1-step etchant-and-primer technique .Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop.2003;124(4):410.
[33] Summers A,Kao E,Gimore J,et al.Comparison of bond strength between a conventional resin adhesive and a resin-modified glass ionomer adhesive an in vitro and in vivo study.Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop.2004;126(2):200 .
[34] Aschcraft DB,Staley RN,J akobsen J R. Fluoride release and shear bond strengths of there light-cured glass-ionomer cements.Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop.1997;111(3):260-265.
[35] Sorensen JA ,Engelman MJ,Torres TJ,et al.Shear bond strength of composite resin to porcelain.Int J Prosthod. 1991;4(1):17-23.
[36] Della Bona A,van Noort R.Shear vs. tensile bond strength of resin composite bonded to ceramic.J Dent Res.1995;74(9): 1591-1596.
[37] Guan G,Takano-YamamotoT,M iyamoto M,et al.An approach to enhance the interface adhesion between an orthodontic plastic bracket and adhesive.EurJ Orthod. 2001;23(4):425.
[38] Caccoiafesta V,Sfondrini MF,Ricciardi A,et al.Evaluation of friction of stainless steel and esthetic self-ligating brackets in various bracket-archwire combinations.Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop.2003;124(4):395.
[39] 刘筱琳,辜岷,白丁.陶瓷托槽的去黏结方法及其对牙釉质表面的影响[J].国外医学:口腔医学分册,2010,125(3):329.
[40] Schmage P, Nergiz I, Herrmann W, et al.Influence of various surface conditioning methods on the bond strength of metal brackets to ceramic surfaces.Am J Orthod Dentofac Orthop. 2003;123(6):540-546.
[41] Gillis I,Redlich M.The effect of different porcelain conditioning techniques on shear bond strength of stainless steel brackets.Am J Orthod Dentofac Orthop.1998;114(4):387-392.
[42] Guan G,Takano-Yamamoto T,M iyamoto M,et al.Shear bond strengths of orthodontic plastic brackets.Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop.2000;117(4):438.
[43] Chung KH,Huang YC.Bonding strengths of porcelain repair systems with various surface treatments.J Prosthet Dent. 1997;78(3):267-274.
[44] 林珠,段银钟.口腔正畸治疗学[M].西安:世界图书出版社公司, 2000:550.
[45] Theodorakopoulou LP,Sadow sky PL,Jacobson A,et al.Evaluation of the debonding characteristics of 2 ceramic brackets: an in vitro study.Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 2004;125(3):329.
[46] Whitlock BO 3rd,Eick WJ,Ackerman RJ Jr,et al.Shear bond strength of ceramic brackets bonded to porcelain.Am J Orthod Dentofac Orthop.1994;106(4):358-364.
[47] Iliadi A,Baumgartner S,Athanasiou AE,et al.Effect of intraoral aging on the setting status of resin composite and glass ionomer orthodontic adhesives.Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 2014;145(4):425-433.
[48] Yaman BC,Ozer F,Takeichi T,et al.Effect of thermomechanical aging on bond strength and interface morphology of glass fiber and zirconia posts bonded with a self-etch adhesive and a self-adhesive resin cement to natural teeth.J Prosthet Dent. 2014. pii: S0022-3913(14)00031-6.
[49] Buruiana T,Nechifor M,Melinte V,et al.Synthesis of poly(alkenoic acid) with L-leucine residue and methacrylate photopolymerizable groups useful in formulating dental restorative materials.J Biomater Sci Polym Ed. 2014. [Epub ahead of print]
[50] Keul C,Müller-Hahl M,Eichberger M,et al.Impact of different adhesives on work of adhesion between CAD/CAM polymers and resin composite cements.J Dent. 2014. pii: S0300-5712 (14)00071-2.
[51] Hussein AS,Ghanim AM,Abu-Hassan MI,et al.Knowledge, management and perceived barriers to treatment of molar-incisor hypomineralisation in general dental practitioners and dental nurses in Malaysia.Eur Arch Paediatr Dent. 2014. [Epub ahead of print]
[52] Pawlus B,Dyszkiewicz A,Spidlen M.A tensomeric and planimetric evaluation of the durability of the bond between an orthodontic bracket and enamel.Acta Bioeng Biomech. 2013; 15(4):33-42.
[53] Purmal K,Alam MK,Sukumaran P.Shear bond strength of orthodontic buccal tubes to porcelain.Dent Res J (Isfahan). 2013;10(1):81-86.
[54] Al-Kawari HM,Al-Jobair AM.Effect of different preventive agents on bracket shear bond strength: in vitro study.BMC Oral Health. 2014;14(1):28.
[55] Nee A,Chan K,Kang H,et al.Longitudinal monitoring of demineralization peripheral to orthodontic brackets using cross polarization optical coherence tomography.J Dent. 2014. pii: S0300-5712(14)00061-X. doi: 10.1016/j.jdent. 2014.02.011. [Epub ahead of print]
[56] Singh C,Dua V,Vyas M,et al.Evaluation of the antimicrobial and physical properties of an orthodontic photo-activated adhesive modified with an antiplaque agent: an in vitro study.Indian J Dent Res. 2013;24(6):694-700.
[57] Bahnasi FI,Abd-Rahman AN,Abu-Hassan MI.Effects of recycling and bonding agent application on bond strength of stainless steel orthodontic brackets.J Clin Exp Dent. 2013; 5(4): e197-202.
[58] Sharma P,Valiathan A,Arora A,et al.A comparative evaluation of the retention of metallic brackets bonded with resin-modified glass ionomer cement under different enamel preparations: A pilot study.Contemp Clin Dent. 2013;4(2):140-146.
[59] Dubernard C,Raynal P,Tramini P.Comparative study of enamel adhesion between RelyX™ Unicem® (3M), a self-adhesive bonding agent, and the combination of MIP® (3M), a hydrophilic adhesive, and Transbond Supreme Low Viscosity® (3M), a traditional hydrophobic adhesive.Int Orthod. 2013;11(3):247-261.
[60] Güngör AY,Alkis H,Turkkahraman H.Effects of contamination by either blood or a hemostatic agent on the shear bond strength of orthodontic buttons.Korean J Orthod. 2013;43(2): 96-100.
[61] Wang Y,Liu S,Pei D,et al.Effect of an 8.0% arginine and calcium carbonate in-office desensitizing paste on the microtensile bond strength of self-etching dental adhesives to human dentin.Am J Dent. 2012;25(5):281-286.
[62] Manfred L,Covell DA,Crowe JJ,et al.A novel biomimetic orthodontic bonding agent helps prevent white spot lesions adjacent to brackets.Angle Orthod.2013;83(1):97-103.
[63] Fleming PS, Johal A, Pandis N.Self-etch primers and conventional acid-etch technique for orthodontic bonding: a systematic review and meta-analysis.Am J Orthod Dentofacial Orthop. 2012;142(1):83-94.
[64] Banerjee S, Banerjee R.A comparative evaluation of the shear bond strength of five different orthodontic bonding agents polymerized using halogen and light-emitting diode curing lights: an in vitro investigation.Indian J Dent Res. 2011;22(5):731-732.
[65] Brown ML,Davis HB,Tufekci E,et al.Ion release from a novel orthodontic resin bonding agent for the reduction and/or prevention of white spot lesions. An in vitro study.Angle Orthod. 2011;81(6):1014-1820.
[66] Neelagiri K,Kundabala M,Shashi RA,et al.Effects of saliva contamination and decontamination procedures on shear bond strength of self-etch dentine bonding systems: An in vitro study.J Conserv Dent. 2010;13(2):71-75.
[67] Tabrizi A, Cakirer B.A comparative evaluation of casein phosphopeptide-amorphous calcium phosphate and fluoride on the shear bond strength of orthodontic brackets.Eur J Orthod. 2011;33(3):282-287.
[68] Pithon MM,dos Santos RL,Ruellas AC,et al.One-component self-etching primer: a seventh generation of orthodontic bonding system?Eur J Orthod.2010;32(5):567-570.
[69] Foek DL,Ozcan M,Krebs E,et al.Adhesive properties of bonded orthodontic retainers to enamel: stainless steel wire vs fiber-reinforced composites.J Adhes Dent.2009;11(5): 381-390.
[70] Saito K,Hayakawa T,Kawabata R,et al.In vitro antibacterial and cytotoxicity assessments of an orthodontic bonding agent containing benzalkonium chloride.Angle Orthod.2009;79(2): 331-337.
[71] Keçik D,Cehreli SB,Sar C,et al.Effect of acidulated phosphate fluoride and casein phosphopeptide-amorphous calcium phosphate application on shear bond strength of orthodontic brackets.Angle Orthod.2008;78(1):129-133.
[72] Armstrong D,Shen G,Petocz P,et al.Excess adhesive flash upon bracket placement. A typodont study comparing APC PLUS and Transbond XT.Angle Orthod.2007;77(6): 1101-1108.
[73] Saito K,Hayakawa T,Kawabata R,et al.Antibacterial activity and shear bond strength of 4-methacryloxyethyl trimellitate anhydride/methyl methacrylate-tri-n-butyl borane resin containing an antibacterial agent.Angle Orthod.2007;77(3): 532-536.