Gaze characteristics of emotional faces in depressed patients: a Meta-analysis based on eye movement studies

doi:10.12307/2022.836

Abstract

Abstract: OBJECTIVE: Relevant Meta-analyses have reported that there is a significant negative fixation pattern in depressed patients, but it is unclear about the magnitude of this pattern and the difference in gaze indicators under different stimuli. To this end, the article systematically evaluates the gaze characteristics of eye tracking in patients with depression under different emotional tasks, providing a reference for clinical outcome and prognostic evaluation.
METHODS: PubMed, The Cochrane Library, EMbase, Web of science, CBM, CNKI, WanFang Database, and VIP database were electronically searched to collect case-control studies on eye tracking in depressive patients from their inception to September 5th, 2021. Two researchers independently screened literature, extracted data and the Newcastle-Ottawa Scale was used to evaluate the quality of the included studies. Meta-analysis was performed by using RevMan5.4 software.
RESULTS: A total of 12 case-control studies were included, in which 231 subjects (depressed patients) were in the case group and 307 in the control group. The Newcastle-Ottawa Scale scores of the included studies were 5 and above, indicating a higher quality of the included studies. The results of Meta-analysis showed that: for different stimulus types, compared with the control group, the fixation duration of depressed patients was significantly reduced under the positive stimulus [Standardized mean difference (SMD)positive=-1.00, 95% confidence interval (CI) (-1.88, -0.12), P=0.03], and was significantly increased under the negative stimulus [SMDnegative=0.77, 95% CI (0.50, 1.04), P < 0.000 01]. There was no significant difference in fixation duration under the neutral stimulus [SMDneutral=-0.17, 95%CI (-0.48, 0.14), P=0.28]. There was no significant difference in the first fixation duration between the case and control groups [SMDpositive=0.18, 95% CI (-0.25, 0.61), P=0.42; SMDneutral=-0.19, 95% CI (-0.46, 0.08), P=0.17; SMDnegative=0.24, 95% CI (-0.04, 0.52), P=0.09]. Compared with the control group, depressed patients showed a significant reduction in the fixation counts under positive and neutral stimuli [SMDpositive=-3.65, 95% CI (-4.59, -2.71), P < 0.000 01; SMDneutral=-1.08, 95% CI (-1.61, -0.56), P < 0.000 1), while the fixation counts in depressed patients increased significantly under negative stimuli [SMDnegative=1.32, 95% CI (0.78, 1.86), P < 0.000 01].
CONCLUSION: There are significant differences in the fixation patterns between depression and healthy individuals, mainly in terms of fixation duration and fixation count. Future studies can explore more eye movement indicators and characteristics of fixation patterns in depressed patients.

Key words: depression, eye movement, health, fixation duration, fixation count, systematic review, Meta-analysis, case-control study

CLC Number:

Xia Haisha, Li Yuxi, Liu Xiaobo, Fan Jin, Zhang Jiaming, Gou Xinyun, Li Juan, Zheng Zhong, Jin Rongjiang. Gaze characteristics of emotional faces in depressed patients: a Meta-analysis based on eye movement studies[J]. Chinese Journal of Tissue Engineering Research, 2022, 26(29): 4735-4741.

Figures/Tables 8

References

[1] KORGAONKAR MS, GOLDSTEIN-PIEKARSKI AN, FORNITO A, et al. Intrinsic connectomes are a predictive biomarker of remission in major depressive disorder. Mol Psychiatry. 2020;25(7):1537-1549.
[2] FRIEDRICH MJ. Depression is the leading cause of disability around the world. JAMA. 2017;317(15):1517.
[3] 李则宣.抑郁症的表观遗传学机制:涉及认知灵活性的证据[J].济宁医学院学报, 2017,40(5):361-365.
[4] TAYLOR JL, JOHN CH. Attentional and memory bias in persecutory delusions and depression. Psychopathology. 2004;37(5): 233-241.
[5] PARSONS S. Does attention bias modification induce structural brain changes? A commentary on Abend et al. (2019). Biol Psychol. 2020;152:107866.
[6] KOSTER EH, DE LISSNYDER E, DERAKSHAN N, et al. Understanding depressive rumination from a cognitive science perspective: the impaired disengagement hypothesis. Clin Psychol Rev. 2011;31(1):138-145.
[7] PARRA MA, SáNCHEZ MG, VALENCIA S, et al. Attentional bias during emotional processing: evidence from an emotional flanker task using IAPS. Cogn Emot. 2018; 32(2):275-285.
[8] PRICE RB, DUMAN R. Neuroplasticity in cognitive and psychological mechanisms of depression: an integrative model. Mol Psychiatry. 2020;25(3):530-543.
[9] RAYNER K. Eye movements in reading and information processing. Psychol Bull. 1978;85(3):618-660.
[10] ASHRAF H, SODERGREN MH, MERALI N, et al. Eye-tracking technology in medical education: a systematic review. Med Teach. 2018;40(1):62-69.
[11] 徐阿娜.眼动检测仪辅助诊断精神分裂症的临床效果及可行性分析[J].中国医疗器械信息,2021,27(18):164-165.
[12] STOLICYN A, STEELE JD, SERIèS P. Prediction of depression symptoms in individual subjects with face and eye movement tracking. Psychol Med. 2020;9:1-9.
[13] ECKSTEIN MK, GUERRA-CARRILLO B, MILLER SINGLEY AT, et al. Beyond eye gaze: what else can eyetracking reveal about cognition and cognitive development? Dev Cogn Neurosci. 2017;25:69-91.
[14] ARMSTRONG T, OLATUNJI BO. Eye tracking of attention in the affective disorders: a meta-analytic review and synthesis. Clin Psychol Rev. 2012;32(8):704-723.
[15] SUSLOW T, HUßLACK A, KERSTING A, et al. Attentional biases to emotional information in clinical depression: a systematic and meta-analytic review of eye tracking findings. J Affect Disord. 2020;274:632-642.
[16] Wells G. The Newcastle-Ottawa Scale (NOS) for Assessing the Quality of Non-Randomised Studies in Meta-Analyses// Symposium on Systematic Reviews: Beyond the Basics. 2014.
[17] AKRAM U, ELLIS JG, CAU G, et al. Eye tracking and attentional bias for depressive internet memes in depression. Exp Brain Res. 2021;239(2):575-581.
[18] 曹爽,吴迪,邢辰,等.抑郁症患者面孔识别注意偏向的时间进程研究[J].中华行为医学与脑科学杂志,2019,28(12):1075-1080.
[19] EIZENMAN M, YU LH, GRUPP L, et al. A naturalistic visual scanning approach to assess selective attention in major depressive disorder. Psychiatry Res. 2003; 118(2):117-128.
[20] GARCíA-BLANCO A, SALMERóN L, PEREA M. Attentional capture by emotional scenes across episodes in bipolar disorder: evidence from a free-viewing task. Biol Psychol. 2015;108:36-42.
[21] ISAAC L, VRIJSEN JN, RINCK M, et al. Shorter gaze duration for happy faces in current but not remitted depression: evidence from eye movements. Psychiatry Res. 2014;218(1-2): 79-86.
[22] KLAWOHN J, BRUCHNAK A, BURANI K, et al. Aberrant attentional bias to sad faces in depression and the role of stressful life events: evidence from an eye-tracking paradigm. Behav Res Ther. 2020;135:103762.
[23] LANZA C, MüLLER C, RIEPE MW. Positive mood on negative self-statements: paradoxical intervention in geriatric patients with major depressive disorder. Aging Ment Health. 2018;22(6):748-754.
[24] 刘睿.基于眼动指标的抑郁评估模型研究[D].成都:西南交通大学,2020.
[25] NEWMAN K, QUIGLEY L, FERNANDEZ A, et al. Concurrent and prospective relations between attentional biases for emotional images and relapse to depression. Cogn Ther Res. 2019;43(5):893-909.
[26] NOIRET N, CARVALHO N, LAURENT É, et al. Visual scanning behavior during processing of emotional faces in older adults with major depression. Aging Ment Health. 2015; 19(3):264-273.
[27] RANTANEN M, HAUTALA J, LOBERG O, et al. Attentional bias towards interpersonal aggression in depression - an eye movement study. Scand J Psychol. 2021;62(5):639-647.
[28] SEARS CR, NEWMAN KR, FERENCE JD, et al. Attention to emotional images in previously depressed individuals: an eye-tracking study. Cogn Ther Res. 2011;35(6):517-528.
[29] BEEVERS CG, CLASEN PC, ENOCK PM, et al. Attention bias modification for major depressive disorder: effects on attention bias, resting state connectivity, and symptom change. J Abnorm Psychol. 2015;124(3):463-475.
[30] WOOLRIDGE SM, HARRISON GW, BEST MW, et al. Attention bias modification in depression: a randomized trial using a novel, reward-based, eye-tracking approach. J Behav Ther Exp Psychiatry. 2021;71:101621.
[31] YANG W, ZHANG JX, DING Z, et al. Attention bias modification treatment for adolescents with major depression: a randomized controlled trial. J Am Acad Child Adolesc Psychiatry. 2016;55(3):208-218.
[32] HERMANS D, VANSTEENWEGEN D, EELEN P. Eye movement registration as a continuous index of attention deployment: data from a group of spider anxious students. Cogn Emotion. 1999;13(4):419-434.
[33] NIEHORSTER DC, ZEMBLYS R, BEELDERS T, et al. Characterizing gaze position signals and synthesizing noise during fixations in eye-tracking data. Behav Res Methods. 2020;52(6):2515-2534.
[34] 姜婷婷,吴茜,徐亚苹,等.眼动追踪技术在国外信息行为研究中的应用[J].情报学报,2020,39(2):217-230.
[35] 闫志明,郭喜莲,王睿.多媒体学习研究中眼动指标述评[J].现代教育技术,2018, 28(5):33-39.
[36] 孙文芳,王馨悦,王长生,等.专家运动员的视觉搜索特征:基于眼动研究的Meta分析[J].天津体育学院学报,2018, 33(4):321-328.
[37] FOLAND-ROSS LC, GOTLIB IH. Cognitive and neural aspects of information processing in major depressive disorder: an integrative perspective. Front Psychol. 2012;3:489.
[38] LAZAROV A, BEN-ZION Z, SHAMAI D, et al. Free viewing of sad and happy faces in depression: a potential target for attention bias modification. J Affect Disord. 2018;238: 94-100.
[39] DUQUE A, VáZQUEZ C. Double attention bias for positive and negative emotional faces in clinical depression: evidence from an eye-tracking study. J Behav Ther Exp Psychiatry. 2015;46:107-114.
[40] ZHANG G, YUAN B, HUA H, et al. Individual differences in first-pass fixation duration in reading are related to resting-state functional connectivity. Brain Lang. 2021; 213:104893.
[41] 徐西良.复发性抑郁缓解期个体注意偏向的眼动及认知干预实验研究[D].南昌:江西师范大学,2013.
[42] 范亮亮.首发抑郁障碍患者情绪面孔注意偏向的眼动研究[D].新乡:新乡医学院,2017.
[43] WERMES R, LINCOLN TM, HELBIG-LANG S. How well can we measure visual attention? psychometric properties of manual response times and first fixation latencies in a visual search paradigm. Cogn Ther Res. 2017;41(4):588-599.
[44] SKINNER IW, HüBSCHER M, MOSELEY GL, et al. The reliability of eyetracking to assess attentional bias to threatening words in healthy individuals. Behav Res Methods. 2018;50(5):1778-1792.
[45] 任翰林,黄亮,郑玉玮,等.自闭症谱系障碍儿童的肢体情绪加工特征:来自眼动的证据[J].中国临床心理学杂志, 2021,29(1):8-13.